Health Care Insanity

Look, most of us agree that we need some kind of health care reform. I’m willing to entertain more government regulation of health care than I entertain in most other industries because health care is, indeed, something that everybody should have access to. This is a moral truth that all Christians should agree on, although good Christians can surely disagree on the best way to provide that access.

But the health care plans being foisted upon us by President Barack Obama (D) and the Democratic super-majorities in both houses of Congress are pretty reprehensible. While some parts of these plans are fine (like limitations on insurance companies holding ‘preexisting conditions’ against you), the whole idea of a government plan—even as an optional alternative to private plans—is frightening. With artificially limited prices, this government plan will likely supplant private plans in time and it will almost definitely begin to exhibit the same problems that all other public health care plans have exhibited in countries that have attempted this dangerous experiment. Beyond these ‘big picture’ concerns, however, there is the fact that the plans being considered in Congress are thousands of pages long and nobody—nobody—has actually read them in their entirety.

Doesn’t that scare you? Doesn’t it frighten you that Congress might pass a massive rewrite of our health care system un-read? It should. If they don’t know what’s in the thing, how can anybody know what it will do to our health care system?

House: Framed and Roofed

house-roofedMelissa and I ran out to the house on Sunday afternoon just to see the progress. As you can see, the whole house is framed and has a roof and everything. Supposedly it will still be done and ready for delivery in a November-ish time frame.

Now we just need to get everything set up with the loan . . . boy that’s a headache all its own. I’ll get into that later.

I do really wish that we could simplify the process of buying houses, buying cars, buying cell phones, etc. There’s no need to layer complexity upon complexity.

Metro Continues to Fail

The Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority (WMATA) has got some explaining to do. According to yet another damning report on MetroRail that appeared in The Washington Post yesterday, the apparently failure-prone ‘fail safe’ Automatic Train Protection (ATP) system is again at the center of the report.

Metro has a two-layer system designed to prevent trains from slamming into one another. First, Automatic Train Control (ATC) usually runs the trains automatically and makes sure that trains don’t enter a ‘block’ (circuit) occupied by another train. If ATC is off and the trains are running manually, or if ATC fails, the secondary ATP system [supposedly] kicks-in and cuts power to a train entering an occupied block.

The problem is that both systems rely on a single, non-redundant network of track circuits. If a track circuit fails, both ‘layers’ of the protection system evaporate into nothingness. This is how the collision happened in June; both layers of the ‘fail-safe’ system got bad data from one bad track circuit and, because there was no independent backup, people died.

‘Submission’ is a Dirty Word

Writing for Catholic Exchange, Pat Gillespie tells a wonderful anecdote about three runaway teenagers that visited his family some years ago and, in a broader sense, how irrationally opposed our western society has become toward the ideas of authority and submission. We all expect others to behave in accordance with societal norms or social standards, and yet we chafe at the idea of following those very norms when we disagree with them for our own selfish reasons.

I’m as guilty as anybody in this respect. As my parents can surely attest, I began to test the authorities in my life early. I tested my family, I tested my schools, and I tested my governments. I still do some of this today in the form of respectful dissent and (in rare instances) civil disobedience. In my younger days, however, my disobedience (while sometimes valid and justified) was too often just my annoying the authorities for no other reason than that they were authorities. This is fairly normal and expected for teenagers, but many adults in western society seem to have never grown out of this phase. Gillespie summed it up in his piece, talking about the three runaways:

I’m sure they took for granted that the world would continue to function according to laws and standards that make community and social life possible, but I don’t think they saw any personal responsibility in making that work by any submission to authority on their part.

Hallway Roadblock

roadblockIt’s one thing to put up a sign to discourage somebody from entering a room. It’s another to put up some caution tape and a sign. It’s quite another to put up caution tape, a sign, an office chair, and four high chairs. I think somebody wants to make sure people stay out of the fellowship hall!

Hey, if you’re going to do something, you might as well do it all the way.

The only thing missing from this scene is some kind of guard animal. I’d have liked to have seen a bunch of angry parakeets, rabid wombats, poisonous geckos, wiggly earthworms, or something like that as a second layer of defense.

Or at least a couple more office chairs! Come on!

Scott Bradford is a writer and technologist who has been putting his opinions online since 1995. He believes in three inviolable human rights: life, liberty, and property. He is a Catholic Christian who worships the trinitarian God described in the Nicene Creed. Scott is a husband, nerd, pet lover, and AMC/Jeep enthusiast with a B.S. degree in public administration from George Mason University.